Study: E-Cigarettes Do Not Help People Quit Smoking

Written by Alexandra Sifferlin – TIME
See original article here

Public health experts continue to debate whether e-cigarettes are a better option than smoking tobacco, or just an alternative way for smokers to inhale nicotine

Marlboro Cigarette & Electronic CigaretteA new, but relatively small, study suggests that e-cigarettes do not help smokers quit or reduce their use of conventional cigarettes.

The study, published in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine looked at self-reports from 949 smokers–88 who used e-cigarettes at the start of the study–and sought to determine whether e-cigarette use was linked to successfully quitting regular cigarettes, or at least lessening consumption at the end of a year.

The researchers found that this was not the case, and despite their small study size and time period, they concluded that their data adds to the current body of evidence that e-cigarettes do not help people quit smoking. “Regulations should prohibit advertising claiming or suggesting that e-cigarettes are effective smoking cessation devices until claims are supported by scientific evidence,” the study authors write.

Whether e-cigarettes are a better option than tobacco cigarettes, or just an alternative way for smokers to inhale nicotine, is a question public health experts continue to debate. Since e-cigarettes do not contain tobacco, some argue they are the lesser of two evils, and that encouraging people to use nicotine products on the less dangerous side of the spectrum is ultimately better for them, and could even help them wean them off actual cigarettes. The problem is that e-cigarettes have not been around long enough for accurate research on their perceived dangers or benefits.

The study is not the first though to poke holes in the theory that e-cigarettes steer people away from standard cigarettes. Earlier this month, another study found that adolescents who use cigarettes are more likely to smoke other tobacco products and cigarettes. The study couldn’t confirm whether smoking e-cigarettes made teens more likely to smoke in general, but it showed it wasn’t a deterrent.

In a corressponding editorial, Dr. Mitchell Katz, deputy editor of JAMA Internal Medicine wrote: “Unfortunately, the evidence on whether e-cigarettes help smokers to quit is contradictory and inconclusive. [The researchers] increase the weight of evidence indicating that e-cigarettes are not associated with higher rates of smoking cessation.”

Read the original article here: http://time.com/36090/study-e-cigarettes-do-not-help-people-quit-smoking

Bookmark the permalink.

2 Comments

  1. Actually the minute a smoker begins to start using an electronic cigarette, they’ve actually quit smoking tobacco cigarettes…the article above is yet another ploy, no desperate attempt to discredit the electronic cigarette. Who has to gain by trying to discredit the use of electronic cigarettes, well the pharmaceutical companies of course. People may say that they’ve already lost billions of £’s and $’s, but can you imagine how much they would stand to lose if people took their own life in their hands and decided not to violate their bodies anymore, basically becoming well and not in need of cures via tablets, medicines, surgery etc caused by that simple white stick which has 66 known carcinogens in it. Yes it also contains nicotine, and that’s the only reason people smoke cigarettes. Why then is it so hard to understand that people prefer nicotine with distilled water and flavour concentrate to 4000 chemicals, many of which are lethal? Stop the bull, stop the propaganda, you will not stop this very high powered moving train!

  2. It’s not bull, Linda. I’m a nicotine addict like you, but the difference is that I haven’t used it for 1,016 days. When I was in your position, I, too, felt like I was “winning”. I tried all sorts of methods from gums to patches. But the only thing that got me off of the drug was to stop using the drug, not replacing its delivery method.

    I’m not trying to discredit e-cigs because I have a stake in a pharmaceutical. No…I’m discrediting because I know what it’s like to flail and be offered “magic quitting aids” that feel like a small step forward and turn into a huge step backwards.

Leave a Reply